How much more is it worth (to you) for a figure to be 100% complete?

[BigTransformerTrev]

How much more is it worth (to you) for a figure to be 100% complete?


Came across this conundrum this morning:

Trying to complete (which I will prob never do) my Grimlock collection. On ebay I found a Pretender Grimlock - 100% complete - for $78 Aus (including shipping). There was also a Pretender Grimlock, essentially the same level of condition and sticker wear, but was missing the Pretender Shell Gun for only $50 (again, including shipping).

I debated the issue in my head, but in the end I decided it was not worth another $28 simply for a little plastic gun, especially when I could buy a Deluxe Generations toy for the same amount. But I will admit, I will notice his lack-of-gun. And when I started collecting again back in 2001, not being as schooled in TF's as I am now, I bought a lot of figures that were not complete that I now regret not being so (Grotusque missing his wings being a prime example).


So:

A: How much more is it worth to you for a figure to be 100% complete?

B: Does it depend on the missing accessory? (example: you can live with G1 Twin Twist missing his gun, you cant live without G1 AM Soundwave missing Wingthing)

C: Does it depend if the accessory is necessary for full transformation? (examples: G1 Blurr's shield, G1 Erector's trailer)



Discuss :)

[Magnus]

As you've alluded to, it depends on how 'necessary' the part is, and whether or not it makes a major aesthetic/functional difference to the toy. To use your example, if I had a G1 Blurr, I would definitely want the shield.

When I had G1 Snarl, I didn't care that I only had one out of three missiles, since I'd only be displaying him with one missile anyway.

I thought my G1 Hound was complete, but it wasn't until a while later that I realised the little jerry can that attaches to the back of the jeep was missing. This didn't bother me that much, either, since he won't have it on in robot mode, and in vehicle mode I'd be displaying him front-on - also, Hound's jerry can is surprisingly expensive. Something like his gun or missile launcher, however, would be more noticeable, so I would shell out for that (as I did with my G2 Slag's gun).

[Kapryiath]

A: How much more is it worth to you for a figure to be 100% complete?
as a rule , i won't buy anything unless its 100% complete just my personal preference, unless the incomplete figure is dirt cheap or something i can pick up locally at a bargain

B: Does it depend on the missing accessory?
sometimes but only in the case that its an extra missile for a gun that will be filled already etc.
C: Does it depend if the accessory is necessary for full transformation? (examples: G1 Blurr's shield, G1 Erector's trailer)
definately , i have a g1 wheelie thats missing his 'cover' and it shits me that it isn't there

[Sky Shadow]

It means everything. For me, if I have an incomplete toy, it stays in my head, constantly annoying me with its incompleteness until I finally get all the parts or sell it.

[theshape]

Really depends what the best value is. The gun is a $5-$10 part so id go for the $50 one

[Sinnertwin]

It means everything. For me, if I have an incomplete toy, it stays in my head, constantly annoying me with its incompleteness until I finally get all the parts or sell it.

Well said, sir, well said
I can't have an incomplete toy. It would constantly play on my mind. Even if it's something small like missing one of three missiles, to me, that toy is near worthless until it's 100% complete.
And then there are eBay sellers that spout lines like " G1 Prime, 99% complete, only missing it's rifle". That rifle's a little more than 1% :rolleyes: I hate that 99% complete phrase

[Ultra Mackness]

It means everything. For me, if I have an incomplete toy, it stays in my head, constantly annoying me with its incompleteness until I finally get all the parts or sell it.

I couldn't agree more. If I was in your shoes Trev I wouldn't be thinking that the extra $28 is for the gun, for me the extra $28 would be to keep that whispering voice in my head telling me it was incomplete quiet!

[GoktimusPrime]

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y227/goktimusprime/avatars/meme_custserv_zps60a89afd.jpg
If I bought a toy with a missing accessory or part, I'd just bring it back for a refund/exchange (or in the case of a Japanese toy, contact Takara(TOMY)'s customer call centre). :)

[liegeprime]

For me I would prefer a complete toy with all accessories.

[jazzcomp]

Really depends what the best value is. The gun is a $5-$10 part so id go for the $50 one
This!

And if easy to find what's missing. If it's difficult, might as well not buy it incomplete unless it's really a bargain & just want a spare.

[Initial_G]

i prefer 100% complete if possible, if not then at least all the main accessories. eg gun / sword etc

[liegeprime]

go for the $50 one trev, I have a Spare pretender Grimlock gun I can sell you :p:D

[5FDP]

Unless I can easily track down the missing parts (and for cheap), I won't even look twice at the figure. Every TF in my collection is 100% complete with paperwork.

[Deonasis]

Complete is always preferred BUT.. it depends on the scarcity of the missing piece and the purpose of buying the figure.

I like complete figures in my collection and since my TFs are mostly post-Armada buying them complete is not too hard. Once you start talking about pre-Beast Wars i think you have to consider the scale of price vs quality vs completeness.

If i wanted to kitbash a figure accessories are usually not required.

If i wanted a quick look at an interesting dirt cheap figure i can forgo some accessories too.

^All of this has a caveat that i know about the missing bits and do not think i have gotten shafted.



PS. I am looking for a Ramjet minicon that comes partnered with Armada Tidalwave.

[Zommael]

It depends on what the accessory is. If it's necessary for the transformation then I pretty much have to have it. If it's a targetmaster or secondary robot I'd rather have it than not. If it's a fairly generic part like a generic-looking gun then I really don't care.

I'm more likely to care about a missing sword or other weapon than a missing gun. Melee weapons are a bit unusual on Transformers (and swords are cooler than guns anyway), whereas I can usually find a gun lying around if the toy really needs it.

I could not care less about generic accessories such as those that come with Cyberverse Legion toys.

[Bidoofdude]

Everything. I've been having a hard time finding G1 toys complete on places like eBay, and I'm usually pretty angry at "99% complete" things that are missing an integral part of them. I've given up on getting a complete Trypticon, so that reissue better happen.

[BigTransformerTrev]

Unless I can easily track down the missing parts (and for cheap), I won't even look twice at the figure. Every TF in my collection is 100% complete with paperwork.


Everything. I've been having a hard time finding G1 toys complete on places like eBay, and I'm usually pretty angry at "99% complete" things that are missing an integral part of them. I've given up on getting a complete Trypticon, so that reissue better happen.


A: How much more is it worth to you for a figure to be 100% complete?
as a rule , i won't buy anything unless its 100% complete just my personal preference, unless the incomplete figure is dirt cheap or something i can pick up locally at a bargain

B: Does it depend on the missing accessory?
sometimes but only in the case that its an extra missile for a gun that will be filled already etc.
C: Does it depend if the accessory is necessary for full transformation? (examples: G1 Blurr's shield, G1 Erector's trailer)
definately , i have a g1 wheelie thats missing his 'cover' and it shits me that it isn't there


It means everything. For me, if I have an incomplete toy, it stays in my head, constantly annoying me with its incompleteness until I finally get all the parts or sell it.


Well said, sir, well said
I can't have an incomplete toy. It would constantly play on my mind. Even if it's something small like missing one of three missiles, to me, that toy is near worthless until it's 100% complete.
And then there are eBay sellers that spout lines like " G1 Prime, 99% complete, only missing it's rifle". That rifle's a little more than 1% :rolleyes: I hate that 99% complete phrase


I couldn't agree more. If I was in your shoes Trev I wouldn't be thinking that the extra $28 is for the gun, for me the extra $28 would be to keep that whispering voice in my head telling me it was incomplete quiet!

Heh - wow! We have some real purists out there! :D I am in complete agreement that 100% complete is to be preferred, but I think that sometimes it depends. For the 4 main cities (Metro, Trypt, Scorp & Fort Max) I shelled out extra for them to be 100% complete. To pick up some cheap Battlechargers, I forgoed the guns - but I still miss them and want to pick them up one day. In the case of Pretender Grimlock, I couldn't really justify spending another $28 just for his gun, even if it meant him not being completely complete.




As you've alluded to, it depends on how 'necessary' the part is, and whether or not it makes a major aesthetic/functional difference to the toy. To use your example, if I had a G1 Blurr, I would definitely want the shield.

When I had G1 Snarl, I didn't care that I only had one out of three missiles, since I'd only be displaying him with one missile anyway.

I thought my G1 Hound was complete, but it wasn't until a while later that I realised the little jerry can that attaches to the back of the jeep was missing. This didn't bother me that much, either, since he won't have it on in robot mode, and in vehicle mode I'd be displaying him front-on - also, Hound's jerry can is surprisingly expensive. Something like his gun or missile launcher, however, would be more noticeable, so I would shell out for that (as I did with my G2 Slag's gun).


Really depends what the best value is. The gun is a $5-$10 part so id go for the $50 one


This!

And if easy to find what's missing. If it's difficult, might as well not buy it incomplete unless it's really a bargain & just want a spare.


i prefer 100% complete if possible, if not then at least all the main accessories. eg gun / sword etc


Complete is always preferred BUT.. it depends on the scarcity of the missing piece and the purpose of buying the figure.

I like complete figures in my collection and since my TFs are mostly post-Armada buying them complete is not too hard. Once you start talking about pre-Beast Wars i think you have to consider the scale of price vs quality vs completeness.

If i wanted to kitbash a figure accessories are usually not required.

If i wanted a quick look at an interesting dirt cheap figure i can forgo some accessories too.

^All of this has a caveat that i know about the missing bits and do not think i have gotten shafted.


PS. I am looking for a Ramjet minicon that comes partnered with Armada Tidalwave.


It depends on what the accessory is. If it's necessary for the transformation then I pretty much have to have it. If it's a targetmaster or secondary robot I'd rather have it than not. If it's a fairly generic part like a generic-looking gun then I really don't care.

I'm more likely to care about a missing sword or other weapon than a missing gun. Melee weapons are a bit unusual on Transformers (and swords are cooler than guns anyway), whereas I can usually find a gun lying around if the toy really needs it.

I could not care less about generic accessories such as those that come with Cyberverse Legion toys.

This is more the attitude I have chosen to adopt. I will get 100% complete if I can afford it, but if it is something minor and it's a figure I really want, then I am willing to forgo an accessory and try and pick it up down the line. Of course if it is an item necessary for Transformation (Snap Trap's shield for example) then if it's not on offer that's a dealbreaker for me.





If I bought a toy with a missing accessory or part, I'd just bring it back for a refund/exchange (or in the case of a Japanese toy, contact Takara(TOMY)'s customer call centre). :)

More discussing purchasing 2nd hand figures off the internet. When it comes to any item - TF or otherwise - if I buy something new from a store and its not complete I return it post haste!




go for the $50 one trev, I have a Spare pretender Grimlock gun I can sell you :p:D

Sweet! If you are not toying with me (heh - toying) shoot me a message and will see if I can get authorization from the missus :p :D

[liegeprime]

I shall take pics tomorrow, - better lighting and post it here for you to see. Then we can discuss via PM instead if your ok with it so as not to derail the thread. :p

[UltraMarginal]

A: How much more is it worth to you for a figure to be 100% complete?

It tends to be my requirement. I've seen the time and money spent by others trying to complete a loose incomplete figure and while there is some thrill in the chase, it doesn't seem worth it. (and sometimes more expensive)

I got a loose Blaster at a garage sale once, his weapon is fairly scarce due to it's fragility. I found it for sale by a parts seller at Botcon in 2011, he wanted $45 US for it. I didn't buy it.

B: Does it depend on the missing accessory? (example: you can live with G1 Twin Twist missing his gun, you cant live without G1 AM Soundwave missing Wingthing)

it does to a degree, I can't see Blurr being worth anything without the sheild, or a headmaster being worth much without the Headmaster. I eventually found a better condition Blaster with his gun at the parra fair for about $40. Sometimes it's worth the wait.

C: Does it depend if the accessory is necessary for full transformation? (examples: G1 Blurr's shield, G1 Erector's trailer)

Like a lot of others have said, if it's part of the figure in either mode for display I consider it necessary, if it's missing a spare missile that would be stored away otherwise then it's not such a big deal for me. even a G1 missile, if it's going to stand there with an empty launcher, that will bug me, I'd rather wait for a version of the toy that includes the missile so it doesn't bug me.

The trick is knowing if you can get hold of an accessory for a decent price, most often if a piece is missing it's something that's commonly missing or broken and getting a replacement part to fix or replace it could be the most expensive element of completing said vintage figure.

having said all that, I bought a few incomplete Pretenders last year as i'm totally aware that they are pretty crappy toys but I just wanted to check them out and see how the robots transformed and fit inside the shells. I dont' really have any interest in completing them, if I ever change my mind I'll probably look for complete ones instead of spare parts.

[BigTransformerTrev]

Heh - the Pretenders Grimlock showed up today. My wife picked him up from the post office and promptly left him sitting on her desk at work. Grounds for divorce I know, and there is not a jury in the land that wouldn't take my side if I tried for sole custody of our child when she shows this kind of lax attitude to important matters, but I might give her one more shot :p

Besides, a co-worker gave me an Activators DOTM Starscream I didn't have today so I am feeling in a generous mood ;)

[Ultra Raccoon]

Yes it definitely would, if I had an incomplete figure it would bug me forever until I buy the parts that I need or sell it to someone.:D

[DELTAprime]

Nothing I have in my collection is less than 100% complete. I wouldn't buy a Transformer that was 99.9% complete. I even would make sure I got a gun clip for Jetfire if I was in the market for him.

[theshape]

To those people who say they wouldn't buy incomplete. What if the price was really good. Say MiB Jetfire for $100 but no gun clip. Do you buy it or skip it?

[DELTAprime]

To those people who say they wouldn't buy incomplete. What if the price was really good. Say MiB Jetfire for $100 but no gun clip. Do you buy it or skip it?

I'd be willing to get it, but then I would buy a gun clip to complete it.

[Eazy D]

I'm a completionist. Have to have all the accessories. I'm a bit odd in that I also need packaging [boxes/backing cards/instructions/bios] but I don't need foam inserts/plastic blisters.

I have sometimes spent close to the value of the incomplete toy just to get the missing packaging/accessories...it seriously bugs me if I dont

[Omega Metro]

They toy itself would need to be complete. I can handle a missing weapon though but would depend on the toy/price etc.

[Mythirax]

It means everything. For me, if I have an incomplete toy, it stays in my head, constantly annoying me with its incompleteness until I finally get all the parts or sell it.

Same as me. If I've somehow cheaped myself into paying less for a slightly incomplete figure. It will stay in my head for a very long time. Just nagging at me. So I always go complete, and if I get the packaging as well, well that's just a bonus :D