Actually, most reissues are the same quality as the originals. Some are actually improved (e.g. Encore Convoy)... although some are inferior (e.g. Bruticus, Devastator). :o I think most of the value in an original G1 toy is more sentimental; not saying that there's anything at all wrong with that... I personally see sentimental value is being far greater than monetary value -- it's something that you just cannot put a price on (like say a family heirloom). :)
So yeah, when Encore Fortress Maximus comes out, a lot more people will be able to join the "Fort Max Owners Club," but I think there's still only a relatively smaller number of people who can claim to be members of the "Original G1 Fort Max Owners Club." :cool: As others have said, no matter how awesome a reissue is, it will only ever be a reproduction (albeit legitimately done, unlike KOs). ;)
Also the story about just owning it. ;) Our G1 toys are our childhood... each time I look at my G1 collection it's like meeting up with an old childhood friend, only that they never left you. :) That's why when I get a reissue, I still keep my original G1 toy too... I could never* part with my childhood G1 toys, even after getting a reissue. So I personally don't "replace" G1 toys with reissues, but rather I get reissues so I can continue to play with these G1 toys, but my childhood "buddies" end up being "retired" as display pieces. :D The years/decades of memories contained in our G1 toys is something that is truly priceless. e.g. My original G1 Brawn... it's not in the best of conditions; shoulders are loose and one of the original arms has a damaged shoulder clip and scratched chrome (I've since replaced it with an arm from a reissue)... but I'll always love that toy because it was my very first Transformer toy that I got way back in 1984 from HobbyCo on the way to what I was expecting to be a really dull piano concerto (turned out it was, but thankfully Brawn kept me entertained :cool:). It's the toy that "started it all" for me, nearly 3 decades ago! :eek: But yeah, I'm more than happy to buy reissues. The only G1 toys that I have sentimental attachment to are the ones I've already owned since childhood. Someone else's G1 toy holds no such sentimental value for me.
--------------------------------
*There's only ever been 1 exception: Perceptor. That's because I got Perceptor when I was a uni student, so he wasn't exactly a childhood toy, and also the connector for his microscope barrel was always broken anyway. The reissue gave me a brand new minty one, and then there was another OTCA member was really wanted an original G1 Perceptor (but he's not into collecting reissues), so I sold him mine. At least I know it's in the hands of a fellow collector and not in some junkyard or some unappreciative child. :rolleyes: