
Originally Posted by
kup
This is what I wrote about the season 1 finale in another board:
SPOILERS
It took me a few weeks to get over how ******* horrible that Miko episode was and decided to finish watching the remainder of the season.
Yeah, the following episodes are indeed much better (did they change writers? ) although I would not consider the final episodes to be 'great' just decent. I still found the Beast Wars season finales to be far superior and the Prime take on the 'Unicron battle' was not as good as other past interpretation and I will include Armada in that.
My main issue was that I don't really like the whole angle of Earth being Unicron. That was just ridiculous, nonsensical and felt somewhat tacky. Although the 3 final episodes where reasonably well written and executed around this concept, I couldn't get into it so this season finale did fall rather flat with me.
On the good side, it was great to see them use the Marvel lore again (although much cut down) when it comes to the 13 Transformers and the original conflict between Unicron and Primus. It was also good to see some Decepticon and Autobot cooperation to defeat Unicron but it was no where near as epic as past interpretations due to it was just being between Megatron and the tiny Autobot band. This is probably another reason why I felt that the finale was a bit 'flat'.
Another good thing is that they gave us a bit of a unique origin for Prime and Megatron which we haven't seen before. That was somewhat refreshing although it was still a bit nonsensical when it comes to character progression. Megatron's 'fall to evil' was rather sudden with no real logical reason for it aside from 'The people who I originally objected to have denied me so now I will be evil, selfish and a megalomaniac. I will also hate prime because they liked him instead of me' this was a bit odd and rather forced.
Finally, I am not sure how anyone can think that WFC is within the Prime continuity. Although a similar theme was shown as all TF series share, they were considerable differences to how the beginning of the Civil War commences in WFC and in Prime making them as separate continuity wise just as Armada and G1 are. Differences include the backgrounds for both Prime and Megatron's relationship, start of the war as well as the whole prelude leading to Optimus becoming Prime.
Overall, pretty decent finale. Too bad that the last few episodes are not truly representative of the Season as a whole which was mostly mediocre at best. Hopefully we will see further improvements in Season 2 but I am not holding my breath as this show seems to be all about 'ups & downs' with the downs being more prominent than the ups. Yeah, I probably would have enjoyed the finale more if I had gotten into the 'Unicron is Earth' theme but I couldn't, oh well.