This reminds me a bit of the old TF geek code from ATT days
G+++ G1 G2-- BW++ MW BM+ FR FW+ M- #205 D+ AA+ N W++ OQP MUSH-- BC CN OM P250

On this I would be something like
6 Realism
8 Classic/Nostalgic
7 Complexity
2 Simplicity
9 Character Appeal
6 Fiction Accuracy
1 Scale
8 Value
2 Gimmicks/Play Value
8 Originality

However I have a gut feeling that the total scores wouldn't be that comparable.