Need Help

[Robzy]

I totally agree! But I've got a quick question...

I know ignorance is not a defence, but some sellers might say they really didn't know there was a difference. The question is, if they use "Transformers" in the listing, then it has to be a "legit" Transformer, right? But, just putting KOs aside for one minute... how many GoBots or Machine Men do we see listed as "Original Transformers"... surely that's misidentifying those items too, isn't it?

Now, Machine Men aren't KOs, but they're certainly not Transformers either! Yet both MM and KOs are often listed as genuine TFs!

[GoktimusPrime]

A KO Transformer falls under what eBay classifies as a "counterfeit item" which is strictly forbidden under eBay policy.

[gamblor916]

Thanks for the info guys, I'll just fire off a few letters and things and see how it goes. It's not really a big loss, I'm just disappointed at the seller's attitude and the hoops paypal make you jump through to get things done.
I just have one lot to come plus maybe some weapons and things but for the most part I think I'm done with ebay.

[kup]

I want to take a break from Ebay too but when I do, crap that I want appears at excellent prices!

Damn you Skystalker, I need you!

[STL]

I want to take a break from Ebay too but when I do, crap that I want appears at excellent prices!

Ain't that the truth!

[Burn]

Getting back to how E-Bay shouldn't be selling any TF's that aren't genuine TF's ...

What about customs? They're not exactly genuine TF's and the homeages certaintly aren't licensed.

[dirge]

What about customs? They're not exactly genuine TF's and the homeages certaintly aren't licensed.

While strictly speaking they classify as a breach of copyright, they'd likely be let alone by Hasbro since they're art rather than for-profit copying. Plus the originals are legit anyway

[GoktimusPrime]

It depends on the custom - primarily depending on if the character is an infringement of copyright. If you were to kitbash a schoolbus that transformed into a robot using bits of models and action figures (e.g. Gundam, Transformers etc) then it's not a breech of copyright afaik. But if you were to make and sell say Masterpiece Swoop, then yes, that is a breech of copyright because that character is a copyright trademark (and that includes name and likeness).

Years ago ToyFare magazine published an article where eBay staff stated that such customs were illegal and that such action would be taken if such auctions are brought to the attention of eBay staff - I imagine that they usually just cancel the auction.

But as dirge said, I don't think it's something that Hasbro is specifically targetting.