Actually, most reissues are the same quality as the originals. Some are actually improved (e.g. Encore Convoy)... although some are inferior (e.g. Bruticus, Devastator).I think most of the value in an original G1 toy is more sentimental; not saying that there's anything at all wrong with that... I personally see sentimental value is being far greater than monetary value -- it's something that you just cannot put a price on (like say a family heirloom).
So yeah, when Encore Fortress Maximus comes out, a lot more people will be able to join the "Fort Max Owners Club," but I think there's still only a relatively smaller number of people who can claim to be members of the "Original G1 Fort Max Owners Club."As others have said, no matter how awesome a reissue is, it will only ever be a reproduction (albeit legitimately done, unlike KOs).
Also the story about just owning it.Our G1 toys are our childhood... each time I look at my G1 collection it's like meeting up with an old childhood friend, only that they never left you.
That's why when I get a reissue, I still keep my original G1 toy too... I could never* part with my childhood G1 toys, even after getting a reissue. So I personally don't "replace" G1 toys with reissues, but rather I get reissues so I can continue to play with these G1 toys, but my childhood "buddies" end up being "retired" as display pieces.
The years/decades of memories contained in our G1 toys is something that is truly priceless. e.g. My original G1 Brawn... it's not in the best of conditions; shoulders are loose and one of the original arms has a damaged shoulder clip and scratched chrome (I've since replaced it with an arm from a reissue)... but I'll always love that toy because it was my very first Transformer toy that I got way back in 1984 from HobbyCo on the way to what I was expecting to be a really dull piano concerto (turned out it was, but thankfully Brawn kept me entertained
). It's the toy that "started it all" for me, nearly 3 decades ago!
But yeah, I'm more than happy to buy reissues. The only G1 toys that I have sentimental attachment to are the ones I've already owned since childhood. Someone else's G1 toy holds no such sentimental value for me.
--------------------------------
*There's only ever been 1 exception: Perceptor. That's because I got Perceptor when I was a uni student, so he wasn't exactly a childhood toy, and also the connector for his microscope barrel was always broken anyway. The reissue gave me a brand new minty one, and then there was another OTCA member was really wanted an original G1 Perceptor (but he's not into collecting reissues), so I sold him mine. At least I know it's in the hands of a fellow collector and not in some junkyard or some unappreciative child.![]()