Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 27

Thread: Transformers ROTF Comic Prequel: Alliance

  1. #1
    Join Date
    9th Apr 2008
    Location
    WEST AUST
    Posts
    5,076

    Default Transformers ROTF Comic Prequel: Alliance

    hrm wait for number 2

    too short and it just covered the gaps from the movie and ross

    also stated that they knew his kind called him wreckage

    so why were they all uppity when sam said his name was megatron? shouldnt they have discovered that themsleves since they already had for wreckage??

  2. #2
    Join Date
    9th Apr 2008
    Location
    WEST AUST
    Posts
    5,076

    Default

    anyone else read it? post your views

  3. #3
    Join Date
    31st Dec 2007
    Location
    Western Sydney
    Posts
    7,229

    Default

    Looks to be better than the Reign comic. but the reign comic looked good in issue 1 too, it was only after the return to Cybertron and the guessing over which coloured splotch of squiggly lines was meant to be who, that it got bad.

    Art makes the movie characters look somewhat decent.

    I'm mostly reading to see how little it has to do with the actual second film.
    Looking For: Wreckers Saga TPB Collection (with Requiem)

  4. #4
    Join Date
    16th Apr 2008
    Location
    blue mountains
    Posts
    648

    Default

    any one notice the optimus prime peter cullen hologram? lol

  5. #5
    Join Date
    29th Apr 2008
    Location
    Sydney
    Posts
    1,155

    Default

    I quite liked this comic. Mowry tried to get some of the movie's humour in, but it seems comic writers struggle to make Simmons as humourous as he was in the movie.

    I think Mowry admitted on the IDW forums that it was an oversight for Epps and Lennox to have working cell phones (a Real Gear Robot if you look closely), given the whole communications blackout Frenzy caused.
    http://www.tfwiki.net, the Transformers Wiki - Serious intellectual discussion about transforming space robots.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    27th Dec 2007
    Location
    Chadstone, Vic
    Posts
    15,772

    Default

    There was also an easter egg in the vehicle that Ironhide destoryed.

    It's interesting that this book picks up on plot points from the comic book prequels (such as Wreckage being captured by Sector Seven) as much as the actual movie.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    19th Jan 2008
    Location
    Sydneytron
    Posts
    3,988

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by i_amtrunks View Post
    Looks to be better than the Reign comic. but the reign comic looked good in issue 1 too, it was only after the return to Cybertron and the guessing over which coloured splotch of squiggly lines was meant to be who, that it got bad.

    Art makes the movie characters look somewhat decent.

    I'm mostly reading to see how little it has to do with the actual second film.
    I agree with your assesment of Reign and Alliance.

    The Alliance concept seems a lot more interesting than Reign's but we shall see. I'm only reading cause I like Wreckage or the toy anyway, so hopping to see him get some personality.

    They should have made Stockade one of the Sector 7 TF's though.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    4th May 2008
    Location
    Perth
    Posts
    261

    Default

    I loved the first issue and the second issue's ending got me really excited for the movie! Wikid!

  9. #9
    Join Date
    28th Dec 2007
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    8,150

    Default

    Could one of the moderators change the title of the thread to a more general discussion thread for the series?

    I’d probably not even have posted about this one if not for Autocon starting the thread. Thanks man. Despite initially avoiding the Movie comics b/c I wanted to wait for the trade, I relented after I saw Jai Nizzi’s breathtaking covers. I got cover B for the 1st issue and it just oozes atmosphere and presence. There’s a lot to like about this and I’m glad to see another new set of hands on the Transformers franchise as I’d really like to see us give some new writers a go..

    I thought the story itself was above average. One major problem I had was adjusting to the artwork. This isn’t a discredit to Alex Milne, I honestly think this is some of his best work. But what threw me was the fact that I’ve seen it as a live action movie. It really pulled me initially to readjust to this different format. Seeing characters I knew rendered in an entirely different manner. I got over it and suspect with a bit more time will get used to it but by the time the actual movie comes around, I fear I’ll probably find it jarring to balance the two again.

    Onto Alex Milne. Wonderful stuff. I’ve been a harsh critic of Milne always saying that he can sure do pin ups but his storytelling leaves a lot to be desired. No such problems here. I think there’s a page where that guy gets off the jet at the base where he splits a single image into two panels and each carries its own weight of atmosphere. I think he struggled with the human bits a lot more but that could be an extension of the fact that I have preconceived notions of how each of the humans should look and his cartoony style is a departure from that.

    The writing. I could be very harsh on Chris Mowry’s plot but I’m happy to let it go. There’s a number of plot choices he had make and the first and foremost was where to fit this “prequel”. If you read it, it doesn’t feel like a prequel. It feels far more like a sequel. The story is set within the last few scenes of the movie, just after the conclusion of the battle and before the Decepticon bodies are dumped into the ocean. This means Mowry must be quite inventive and work within that space of time without contradicting anything that is to come. That however doesn’t excuse him for some pretty average storytelling. The dialogue after the introduction of that scientist is out of place. There’s a lack of intensity in the initial stages when the Autobots are supposed to rush. The dialogue tries very hard but its not successful. The whole accepting the gig by the Lennox and his buddy comes and goes way too quickly to be convincing. One moment they’re reluctant and the next moment, they’re in?

    The ending was a bit jarring too and at first very disappointing as I was trying to figure how on Earth Starscream was in a protoform shell or whatever it was. But then I guessed it must’ve been from Reign of Starscream which makes it pretty jarring if u are only following this from the movie. A little footnote/caption would’ve helped there.

    Mowry hasn’t really done much with the characters either. Its more of been a straight plot movement story as opposed to much character work. And that’s probably one of its weaknesses and perhaps inherent b/c IDW can only go so far to define the characters without overstepping their boundaries into that of Hasbro and Paramount.

    One of the other problems I think IDW gave themselves was how long they left this too. It should’ve easily been right on the heels of the movie right after the initial adaption. This was when the property was hot and would’ve been more accessible. Now, we feel like we’re still in the last movie as opposed to heading towards the next one b/c the time frame in which the story is set. However, a large part I suspect must have to do with Hasbro and Paramount having a say as well. They wanted to see the direction of ROTF before approving anything and as had been alluded to by Ryall and Denton, the approval process can take a long time. With something as important as ROTF is to the TF franchise, this is something that Hasbro would want to get right so hence why the delay. That’s all reasons for it but in the end it does hurt to call this a prequel when it isn’t. I think Defiance may be more of a success on that front but we’ll see. (And the covers on Defiance look great too!)

    Great Moments
    - Dispensor gets another moment to shine
    - Beautifully rendered Ironhide. There’s no hiding the fact how much I love the toy and by extension the character.

    Nice Moments
    - G1 Easter Eggs: Ironhide alt mode, Long Haul nod, Optimus’ Trailer
    - The fact that the Autobots are still hiding on Earth, not out in the open. Gives it that mystique still though I wonder how they can conceal that fact given their presence in a massive battle that would’ve been the centre of world attention. All the telecommunications was knocked out in the movie but there were still plenty of civilians to witness the giant robots.
    - Barricade issue dealt with – not gracefully but its appreciated
    - Longarm, Salvage , Landmine all appearing

    Cringe Moments
    - Lying to Agent Simmons and then Sam calling up mid-call. It know its supposed to be comedic but there was a lack of facial expression to convey that and it ended up being jarring
    - The whole buddy buddy thing with the Autobots and Captain Lennox. Came out of nowhere. This is right after the big fight in the movie; they’ve fought a battle together but the whole change in attitude to be buddies and cover for the alien robots was just too quick a jump for me
    - An out of the nowhere scientist – do we really need these one? And one with attitude too? It didn’t quite sync for me what made him so special yet his lines were so random and hardly matched the introduction he was given.

    In all, it was above average but not quite excellent yet and I think what IDW here are trying to do here is maximise what they can get out of the movie franchise. Hence why they’ve focused on elaborating between moments in the movie. There are many compromises as a result so don’t expect too much and you won’t be too disappointed. I’d give it a 7/10. It’s not groundbreaking but it’s definitely satisfactory in the job it sets out to do.
    Collection Count (w/ a 12.42% upsize): 3053
    New Family Members: DA-15 Jetwing Prime, DOTM Leader Ironhide, Perfect Effect Reflector, DOTM Shockwave & Skyhammer, eHobby United 3-packs
    Current Desires: Japanese BW Optimal Optimus
    The Holy Grail: Ultmetal Optimus Prime


    Visit the Wonderful World of: The Iacon City Hub-Capital Collection

  10. #10
    Join Date
    29th Apr 2008
    Location
    Sydney
    Posts
    1,155

    Default

    STL, several of your concerns and observations are addressed in the Reign of Starscream, which you should have read before Alliance. ROS takes place during the month in between Mission City and Lennox and Epps asking the Autobots for their help.

    Starscream never changed back into protoform mode. He left Earth in his F-22 form, which is what he is depicted on the last page. Issue 1 of the Reign of Starscream actually shows the altercation between Ironhide and Barricade, and Starscream's return for Barricade after the other Decepticons are killed.


    I figure Lennox's men covering for the Autobots is out of a bond forged between soldiers on the battlefield. I liked the touch of the humans bowing their heads in respect to Jazz, who died provide covering fire so they could retreat. Plus I figure it's the relationship the Autobots will have with Lennox and co in ROTF.


    Jai Nizzi? I think you meant Josh Nizzi.
    http://www.tfwiki.net, the Transformers Wiki - Serious intellectual discussion about transforming space robots.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •