Transformers IDW discussion thread [SPOILER WARNING]

[i_amtrunks]

I think they need two G1 titles. One with more flash and zip with recognisability; one for Furman's world. I may be a critic of Furman but the primary issue is his pacing and shoddy story-telling at times. The universe he is crafting is unique. And I want more.

Another possible path is having two artists on alternating mini-series. This allows them to have less breaks between mini-series. They could have a one month gap between the mini-series, drawn by different artists. They've got a stable of motivated creators who are also fans.

I like both of these ideas, DW may have been largely fanwank and badly written, but there was that element of "fun" to it, somewhat similar to the G1 cartoon, it was more or less a light hearted romp, with the occasional darker element.

Having the dark and complex Furmanverse and another lighter "pick up and read" style series wouldnt hurt at all. An ongoing "Hearts of Steel" style story would be ideal.

And thanks for the actual numbers, I knew that between Infiltration #0 and #1 there was over 50% decline, but I didnt realise that it was down to under 15,000 sales.

[STL]

Speculation time:

What does everyone think about the two dead humans. If Furman's dialogue is anything to go by, I'm thinking with the severe mental damage, the two of them are very likely to become Headmasters.

Does anyone think that the double solicitation of Spotlights in March might have anything to do with the fact that Furman doesn't have enough room to work with in Devastation? Arcee and Grimlock seem to be the best candidates here to give perspective on the outcomes from the two key encounters.

Could Arcee be the psycho trying to destroy Monstructor? That'd be a very interesting twist. The rest of thee Autobots seem to be in her way according to what's been said about the issue.

And Grimlock might be teaming up with Megatron? If the Autobots are abandoning Earth, he might have no choice. Especially with his fellow Dinobots still in stasis. He's got the type of character that could forge an alliance with Megatron too of all the Autobots.

Another possibility I'm giddy at is what if Megatron and Starscream defeat the Reapers and as a result are viewed as heroes by the Earth population. The bigwigs in Skywatch might know otherwise but to the public they're adoring the big new alien robots. And with that adulation, Megatron gets more Ore-13 and precious Earth energon to lead into the All Hail Megatron event this summer? It's a bit far fetched but that would be an awesome twist. The Autobots then would be seen as villains by Earth. IDW's version of Megatron seems savy enough to do this. Recall his lines in #5 when he sees what Astrotrain, Blitzwing and co. were doing behind his back? I think it'd make Megs all that more sinister and creepy.

And I assume Optimus has instructed Hound's team to no longer to go to Earth. I'm interested whether Sideswipe will defy those orders and go to Earth anyway. Also would love to see his reaction to Sunstreaker.

[i_amtrunks]

Another possibility I'm giddy at is what if Megatron and Starscream defeat the Reapers and as a result are viewed as heroes by the Earth population. The bigwigs in Skywatch might know otherwise but to the public they're adoring the big new alien robots. And with that adulation, Megatron gets more Ore-13 and precious Earth energon to lead into the All Hail Megatron event this summer? It's a bit far fetched but that would be an awesome twist. The Autobots then would be seen as villains by Earth. IDW's version of Megatron seems savy enough to do this. Recall his lines in #5 when he sees what Astrotrain, Blitzwing and co. were doing behind his back? I think it'd make Megs all that more sinister and creepy.

And I assume Optimus has instructed Hound's team to no longer to go to Earth. I'm interested whether Sideswipe will defy those orders and go to Earth anyway. Also would love to see his reaction to Sunstreaker.

That's almost the same thinking as myself. Except I expect Hot Rod and maybe even Nightbeat to hang back on Earth, Sideswipe, and even Grimlock will probably team up with them.

I am not sure what Arcee will be doing, but I agree, breaking Monstructor out (perhaps as another Jhiaxus experiment) makes sense. I'd love to see Springer and the Wreckers introduced in the next "-tion" book helping Prime out.

I expect Galvatron to team up with the Decepticons, in an effort to overthrow Nemesis Prime.

[STL]

Thoughts on this? It's supposed to be incontinuity... just feels like a bad move to me.

http://www.seibertron.com/energonpub...ic.php?t=35867

Nice to see Steve Buccellato doing some pencils, I only ever recalled him as a colourist on the Uncanny X-Men book.

[Paulbot]

Yeah it's very odd for Furman to spoil maybe 6 months(?) worth of comics.

[i_amtrunks]

I think its a good move, we all had guessed at least some of the plot points that are mentioned.

Also Hunter never mentions the outcomes of any of his experiences. All we really know is that Hunter/Sunstreaker fight Scorponok, see the Dead Universe, ally with Grimlock and fight a full Decepticon alliance, and survives.

We know no details, outcomes, or consequences. Hell at the end of the "-tion" series it could very well be Sunstreaker vs. the Decepticons!

All it's done is spell out all the future plot points that have had plenty of clues and hints left around beforehand.