I understand both TF76 and Bruticus's positions. And I think it might come down to whether or not the acquirer has any other Bruticuses.

I do not. As a result, I'm quite smitten with this toy, because regardless of its problems, it's still a G1 Bruticus, which i generally consider to be an awesome toy.

Now, if I already had a G1 Bruticus, or an excellent/mint condition one at that, I would find this toy very disappointing.

But the fact remains, that for someone who doesn't have G1, to acquire a G1 for A$110 or under is wrought with difficulties, e.g. avoiding KOs, different opinions of quality, dealing with untrusted sellers, etc.

So, my opinion is that if you don't have a Bruticus, this is a great option. If you do have one already, and don't need spare parts, packaging or tech spec cards, I'd recommend seeing one in person before buying one.

Further comment and discussion here.