ive polished metal before by using that technique (600 grit to 2000 grit or finer with different cross strokes). It polished up really well to a mirror finish, but from experience, it took quite a bit off the metal and any uneven strokes/pressure will cause uneven abrasion.
so if you were attempting that technique on a thin plastic G1 car windshield then i doubt it will stand up to that method.
how deep are your scratches/smokiness?? if they aren't too deep, perhaps you can try polishing compound (
http://www.hlj.com/product/FNS55937)
and then maybe toothpaste or a polishing cloth?
i haven't tried it yet but it should be less damaging than sandpaper?