Well, this is what I'm trying to ascertain. As a "toy collection", you're probably right. As "stock" for sale, I think I might be able to. Now, in order to prove that indeed it is stock, I have an inventory database, photos of the merchandise (MISB), and receipts for purchases.
The tough part is explaining why I don't have any current income arising from it. I do have a lot of money flowing in to my bank and PayPal account due to the group orders I manage and the hunting I do on behalf of others. I could argue that this very limited revenue is income for this business.
Of course, I'm doing a lot more buying than selling, so naturally, I'm running at a loss. Now, the tax office limits how long you can run at a loss to your own tax benefit (three years I think). So, I should at least get three years of tax benefit for accruing future stock, and then my baseless theory and hope is that somehow due to the nature of the business (time maturing collectibles), I can stave off this period for at least a few more years, if not longer.
Sound reasonable?
I'll be seeing my accountant in a little over a month and I will put this to him. I will of course let you know my results. I was just wondering if anyone had any experience in this area.