I've only played two Zelda games - Wind Waker and Twilight Princess. I wouldn't say the latter was a terrible game, but it wasn't a classic in the way that Wind Waker was (and is). That game really resonated with me in a way that few games do these days. And how can you not like those Korok fellas. Adorable!

EDIT: My Silent Hill replay is going well, I'm up to the Alchemelia Hospital now and am documenting the story in MS Word and taking screen captures as I go. Obsessive? Maybe, but it's fun all the same.