would you pay more for a figure that had it's box

[GoktimusPrime]

I like to buy sealed toys so I know they're new. Any flaws are production errors or my fault, not someone else's.

Excellent points. If it's a production fault, then you should be able to seek recompense (e.g. product exchange, refund, replacement part). My MP-1 Convoy was missing one small panel and my MP Rumble came with two of the same-side piledriver; in both cases, Takara(TOMY) sent me replacement parts. I've had a few local bought TFs that I was able to easily bring back to the store for a refund or exchange (e.g. my Generations Drift came w/ two of the same-side fists).

But another thing is, there are typically no loose versions of the toy available on the secondary market when I buy my toys anyway. With the sole exception of Red Alert, all of my Japanese Masterpieces were pre-ordered. All of my Hasbro MPs were purchased new from Toys R Us. Another advantage with purchasing toys new is that you don't risk inadvertently picking up a counterfeit; while there may be obvious tell-tale signs, it's just one less hassle to worry about. I've handled a counterfeit MP Alert IRL; the quality is rubbish. Although getting a MISB MP Alert off the secondary market ended up costing me ≈$100 (incl. postage; about double what it would've cost me had I pre-ordered it), I was willing to pay the price to get a new-condition legitimate MP Alert off the secondary market (and besides, even if Hasbro were to release this toy locally in future, it would cost $100 at TRU anyway #AURRP ).

[Bidoofdude]

I have always exclusively bought stuff in box, never loose. If it's something like a G1 toy that is really difficult and expensive to find with box, I'll probably get a loose complete one though.

[drifand]

I don't have a big preference .

Sure I take misb as first
Second mib
Third box second hand with minor wear
Forth loose.

I open my toy in regardless of what I bought.

There are Rodimus mp 2nd ver loose ATM.
For just display fun, I wouldn't mind but I have version 1 and is good enough.

It all zooms down to kind of collector you are.
I transform and admire my toys. I don't keep them sealed if I don't need to.
No point getting misb if you never even enjoyed the toy, your intent is for value status not the admiration of the toy at all.

But end of the day, it what makes you happy.
I have met a parent who bought a masterpiece smokescreen for his three year old son, so he wouldn't care what happens to the toy at all.

[Megatran]

Ahhhh... Loose vs Complete package. The age old question.

Sit down & listen to the words of this agony uncle.
Back when I was your age, I'd always go for loose. The looser the better. Cheap, so much fun & happy endings. Those days are well & truly behind me now. These days I'd always recommend to go for the complete package, even if it means having to folk out a bit more moolah. What ever your choice & above all, make sure the other party uses adequate protection.

[Sky Shadow]

Excellent points. If it's a production fault, then you should be able to seek recompense (e.g. product exchange, refund, replacement part).

Well, yeah, although I think there might be a statute of limitations on some toys - and it turns out that sometimes (ironically) it's better to buy second hand toys than ones that are sealed. I opened a MISB Masters of the Universe Multi-Bot from 1986 earlier this year, and it turned out that a loose one would have been in better condition than the sealed one - the plastic had reacted badly with the plastic bags inside the box. It's a bit like the plasticiser issue with Pretender Monster shells.

[drifand]

Well, yeah, although I think there might be a statute of limitations on some toys - and it turns out that sometimes (ironically) it's better to buy second hand toys than ones that are sealed. I opened a MISB Masters of the Universe Multi-Bot from 1986 earlier this year, and it turned out that a loose one would have been in better condition than the sealed one - the plastic had reacted badly with the plastic bags inside the box. It's a bit like the plasticiser issue with Pretender Monster shells.

Hence the risk.

I think what is obvious is,
All new toys, buy misb regardless you are going to open it or not.
All old toys, you need to reconsider.
For old vintage, I rather pay to see a c10 condition toy which I know it's not broken than challenging the risk of a broken part but you choose to believe nothin is wrong as it hasn't been opened before.