I purchased a comic TPB recently on eBay described as "Like New".

The book I received was clearly "used". It had sticker residue on both the front and back covers, scratches on both covers, wear on the binding, a bent front right hand corner, rounding to the top and bottom corners of each page. Acceptable as "used" but nowhere near "like new".

So I left neutral feedback, negatively marking the item description, but everything else was fine and top marks.

The seller has contacted me asking me to remove my feedback and offering me a refund and the return mail costs to do so.

I will take him up on the refund and return mail costs (bit annoying as this book is hard to come by which is why I was willing to keep it). I'm not too sure I should remove the neutral feedback though.

He clearly said he wants it gone so he's a 100% seller, but I feel I have some obligation to other purchasers of his to leave accurate feedback. If I leave my comment than perhaps the next buyer will ask a few more questions which I should have done but I trusted his 100% feedback foolishly.

Any thoughts?