Agreed,
Whether a toy is 1st or 2nd hand is irrelevant by the fact that these poor kids would be lucky to receive anything at all.
I grew up on 2nd hand toys, so yeah a brand new one was certainly a surprise but I would've been just as happy with a 2nd hand toy.
I also have a personal problem with donating to International Charities, shouldn't we help out those in our own backyard first?
Just sayin'...