While I wouldn't necessarily call Identity 'creepy', it is an exceptional movie. The only downside is that it has an ending very similar to the 6th Sense - once you know what happens, watching it again just isn't the same.
Thats true. I watched it in the cinema then bought the dvd when it came out and was just meh? In the cinema it did creep me out... but then I'm not the best to watch scary movies with