Movie Critics Thread

[GoktimusPrime]

Just watched a Bollywood scary movie called A Flat. It's so weird... despite being this dark and serious scary film, it manages to put in no less than two Bollywood style musical scenes... the first one is rather sensual, but the second is really upbeat with music and dancing etc. And it goes on for a while, which really makes the spooky feel of the film feel disjointed. But I've been told that this is what sells in India, and that movies without a musical number tend to not do well, so I guess from a marketing POV it's understandable, but from a story-telling POV it's really quite campy and just stalls the plot during the whole scene like most of the supposedly funny scenes in a Michael Bay film. There's a third musical moment, but it's done better and fits in reasonably well with the scene of the movie (it works more like a musical narrative rather and goes with the flow of the story rather than stalling it).

The soundtrack also sometimes goes over the top in some places, and I think that for a movie of this genre, less would've been more. This movie would've been scarier if the damn soundtrack didn't give away every scary moment. Scary movies are spookier when you've got dead silence and suddenly something freakin' horrifying just jumps at you! The orchestra just does all this build up, so by time you see the scary thing, you've already braced yourself and it's just... well... not as scary. And some of the scary elements weren't terribly original either, but the story does have some nice surprises (particularly with the roles of the protagonist and antagonist) and builds well to its final conclusion.

Trailer

[XMan]

The Winter Soldier.

<Spoilers>

I was blown away by this movie! It was everything I hoped for and more.
I enjoyed how it showcased more of Caps abilities than the previous First Avenger and Avengers, such as when they he gets aboard the pirate ship at the beginning and simply takes down almost everyone whilst running past them, it looked brutal and elegant at the same time.

The espionage and intrigue was also great, and I couldn't help but think of Civil War when SHIELD/HYDRA came after him. The cinema I saw it in was full of people who obviously didn't know who The Winter Soldier was, so when his mask came off it was revealed to be Bucky it was met with a unified 'Gasp!' and whisperings of 'OMG! It's his friend! It's Bucky!' something I haven't experienced at the movies in some time.

I also loved Sam and Steve's relationship, it felt great and natural to me, and Anthony Mackie looked fantastic as The Falcon!

4 Stars from, it would be 5 but, for reasons unknown to me, I found Black Widow to be kinda annoying in this one

[Mythirax]

The Winter Soldier.

Hope you been watching agents of shield :P

[XMan]

Sure have been

[The_Damned]

The Winter Soldier.

<Spoilers>

I was blown away by this movie! It was everything I hoped for and more.
I enjoyed how it showcased more of Caps abilities than the previous First Avenger and Avengers, such as when they he gets aboard the pirate ship at the beginning and simply takes down almost everyone whilst running past them, it looked brutal and elegant at the same time.

The espionage and intrigue was also great, and I couldn't help but think of Civil War when SHIELD/HYDRA came after him. The cinema I saw it in was full of people who obviously didn't know who The Winter Soldier was, so when his mask came off it was revealed to be Bucky it was met with a unified 'Gasp!' and whisperings of 'OMG! It's his friend! It's Bucky!' something I haven't experienced at the movies in some time.

I also loved Sam and Steve's relationship, it felt great and natural to me, and Anthony Mackie looked fantastic as The Falcon!

4 Stars from, it would be 5 but, for reasons unknown to me, I found Black Widow to be kinda annoying in this one

really black widow was the highlight for me :P

[Hursticon]

I knew "Sharknado" was going to be a bad film, going into it... but GOD DAMN!

In all seriousness, I would watch Birdemic over that utter waste of time any day! - At least James Nguyen was trying...

[Paulbot]

Captain America 2 was great. Really enjoyed it. Amazing Spider-Man 2 wasn't.

I saw the new Spidey flick this morning and the more I think about it the more I don't like it. There's all sorts of parallels that should be addressed and could be interesting but aren't because other random things come up. It's like the writers kept coming up with ideas but didn't follow them through and instead you get padding. And multiple super-villain origin stories in your film don't help.

My three favourite superhero movies are all second sequels - X-2, Dark Knight, Spider-Man 2(!) - and Thor 2 and Capt 2 were both really enjoyable so I guess my hopes/expectations were too high for Amazing 2 and they weren't met.

[griffin]

I knew "Sharknado" was going to be a bad film, going into it... but GOD DAMN!

I watched it last night on Channel 99, for a second time, just because it is so bad... but that was the point of the movie. It was almost a parody of the "disaster" genre, by thinking up a disaster that is absurd. And that's why it is so funny. You keep laughing at each stupid thing that they throw in there, and then hate yourself for watching it.

The movie intentionally did "bad" so well, that it actually had more viewers on the second screening, and even more on the third in America.

It is so unique, that it has spawned a sequel... and even the title plays up on it too - "Sharknado 2: The Second One".

[5FDP]

Still trying to forget that Sharknado movie

Saw Amazing Spider-Man 2 (or Spader-Man if you frequent any of the local flea markets ) on the weekend just passed; I give it a solid 6.5 / 10. Better than the first, but still a bit of a disappointment. Should've checked out Captain America based on the opinions above.

[jazzcomp]

Watched Walter Mitty and World War Z -- ho hum....